When the CEO’s Voice Isn’t the CEO: Would Your Cyber Insurance Cover the Transfer?

voice fraud

An accounting employee receives a call that sounds like the CEO. The instructions are urgent: release a payment using updated bank details. An email follows with the account information. The employee sends the money. Later, the company discovers that a criminal used AI-generated audio to impersonate the executive.1  

Yes, it’s real. Cybercriminals can use an executive’s voice to create a fraudulent phone call or voicemail.2  

The immediate question is how do we recover the funds? Another follows quickly: Does our cyber insurance cover this? 

The answers depend on more than whether the company purchased cyber insurance. It requires examining how the policy defines fraud, which coverage applies and what conditions the company must satisfy. An employee-authorized payment can raise different coverage questions. A criminal gaining access to a system and initiating an unauthorized transfer is different from deceiving an employee into sending money. Insurance policies may treat those events differently. 

Coverage labeled “computer fraud” or “funds transfer fraud” should not be assumed to address every impersonation scheme. Look specifically for social engineering fraud, fraudulent instruction or impersonation coverage. Depending on the insurance program, this protection may appear in a cyber policy, a crime policy or an endorsement. 

Ask your advisor to apply the actual wording to a scenario: An employee sends company funds after receiving a convincing but fraudulent instruction. Where does our policy address that loss? 

Six policy details deserve a closer look: 

  1. Does the wording address voice and video impersonation?

An AI impersonation attempt may arrive by telephone, voice message or video call. Review how the policy defines a ‘fraud instruction’ and which communication methods qualify in the policy. Also examine whose identity the criminal must impersonate. Does the provision address executives, employees, vendors and clients? Are there restrictions involving established relationships or authorized requesters? 

Some available coverage expressly addresses impersonations communicated by phone, email, online or in person. That should be confirmed in your own policy. Note: a policy does not necessarily need to use the word “deepfake” to cover the incident. The important question is whether its definitions describe the event. 

  1. What is the actual limit for this loss?

The overall cyber limit may differ substantially from the amount available for social engineering fraud. For illustration reasons only, a policy with a $1 million overall limit could have a $100,000 sublimit. A $250,000 fraudulent transfer would then require evaluating the smaller limit, applicable deductible and other terms. 

Ask: 

  • Is the limit per incident or shared across the policy year? 
  • Could several related transfers count as one loss? 
  • Do investigation or recovery expenses reduce the amount available? 
  • Is a higher limit available? 
  • What is the size of payments your company makes and the potential for multiple transfers before fraud being discovered? 
  1. Does coverage require independent verification?

Your policy may require you to confirm payment instructions another way. For example, a call to a vendor at a known phone number may be required before sending money. Some insurers may waive this requirement after reviewing your payment controls process but charge an additional premium. Check your policy’s exact requirements before a fraudulent payment occurs, so your team knows what it must do for coverage to apply. Determine what your policy requires, who must perform the verification and what evidence should be documented. Then confirm that your accounting procedures reflect those requirements. 

Note: A call from someone claiming to be the vendor does not count as verification. Call the vendor yourself using a trusted phone number already on file.3 

  1. Does the policy cover payments an employee was tricked into making?

Some policies exclude losses when an employee willingly sends money, even if a criminal deceived them. Additional coverage for impersonation or payment scams may cover those losses, subject to limits and requirements. Ask your insurance advisor to explain whether your policy covers this situation, what conditions apply and which losses remain excluded. 

  1. Whose money—and which expenses—are covered?

Identify whether protection applies to company funds, client funds held by the company or both. A business handling money for others should examine that distinction closely. Also separate the stolen payment from the costs surrounding it. Forensic investigation, legal help, data risks and business interruption may involve different coverage provisions. A fraudulent transfer does not automatically trigger every part of a cyber policy. Ask what event activates each coverage and which costs remain the company’s responsibility. 

  1. How do cyber and crime policies work together?

When coverage appears in more than one policy, review how the policies coordinate. Examine applicable deductibles or retentions, ‘other insurance’ provisions and notification requirements. Some programs offer specific wording to coordinate amounts paid under cyber and something called social engineering coverage, e.g., when an employee is tricked, demonstrating that this interaction deserves deliberate review. 

How can Sentinel help? 

Sentinel can help evaluate a realistic impersonation scenario against your cyber and crime policies. That review can identify the applicable coverage, compare limits with payments and highlight conditions that your finance team needs to understand. We can also help assess available options, request clarification from insurers and explain the insurance response process. Where wording leaves an important question unresolved, the goal is to address it before an incident tests the policy. 

Footnotes 

  1. Federal Bureau of Investigation. “Criminals Use Generative Artificial Intelligence to Facilitate Financial Fraud.” December 3, 2024. 
  2. Federal Bureau of Investigation. “Senior U.S. Officials Impersonated in Malicious Messaging Campaign.” May 15, 2025. 
  3. Travelers. “Cyber Security Training.” Resources addressing cyber fraud, social engineering and insurance considerations.  

 Author: Todd Keenan

Cybersecurity Practice

Share on LinkedIn

About The Author

As Director of Specialty Lines, Todd leads the firm’s strategy, placement, and growth of complex and non-standard insurance business lines, including cyber liability.